Foreign Affairs
As an antidote to the American media’s near-myopia about health care in considering the UK and Canada the only foreign countries with any relevance (which has abated somewhat but not nearly enough), some health care headlines from elsewhere in the world.
In Germany, in new poll by the Allensbach Institute indicates that the population is concerned about two-class medicine, with 72 percent of participants saying they are concerned that patients with private insurance get better treatment than those in the public system. And 80 percent of doctors say they don’t have enough time with patients to complete everything they need to.
Further, public sickness funds face deficits next year that are estimated at between 7 and 11 billion euros. Special “ancillary premiums” are likely to be charged by the sickness funds at some point this year and the insurers are seeking, unsuccessfully so far, more money from the government.
In France, the coffers of the national health care system are 9.4 billion euros in the red and conservative politicians there have been making ominous pronouncements about the future of the Sécurité Sociale system as a whole.
In Switzerland, health care premiums could rise up to 20 percent next year. A poll found that some 30 percent of people there may switch insurance companies if premiums go up 10 percent, some 43 percent if they increase 15 percent, and a majority will move to a cheaper company if the rise is indeed 20 percent. In addition, 58 percent say they are against the 30 Swiss franc (~$27) co-pay for visits to the doctor.
Deficits, co-pays, and too short consultations with the doctor. If this all sounds familiar, it should. The US isn’t alone in its problems and no system is perfect, all make trade-off with regard to what they cover and what they cost. All three of the above systems are either private or public-private hybrids that bear lots of similarities to the US system –and to American reform proposals, making it clear that no matter what the outcome of the bills now before Congress, the challenges the US faces aren’t going to magically melt away.
There are no panaceas in either policy or medicine and those who believe there are have been duped. The lesson is clear: look before you leap –and look carefully.
As an antidote to the American media’s near-myopia about health care in considering the UK and Canada the only foreign countries with any relevance (which has abated somewhat but not nearly enough), some health care headlines from elsewhere in the world.
In Germany, in new poll by the Allensbach Institute indicates that the population is concerned about two-class medicine, with 72 percent of participants saying they are concerned that patients with private insurance get better treatment than those in the public system. And 80 percent of doctors say they don’t have enough time with patients to complete everything they need to.
Further, public sickness funds face deficits next year that are estimated at between 7 and 11 billion euros. Special “ancillary premiums” are likely to be charged by the sickness funds at some point this year and the insurers are seeking, unsuccessfully so far, more money from the government.
In France, the coffers of the national health care system are 9.4 billion euros in the red and conservative politicians there have been making ominous pronouncements about the future of the Sécurité Sociale system as a whole.
In Switzerland, health care premiums could rise up to 20 percent next year. A poll found that some 30 percent of people there may switch insurance companies if premiums go up 10 percent, some 43 percent if they increase 15 percent, and a majority will move to a cheaper company if the rise is indeed 20 percent. In addition, 58 percent say they are against the 30 Swiss franc (~$27) co-pay for visits to the doctor.
Deficits, co-pays, and too short consultations with the doctor. If this all sounds familiar, it should. The US isn’t alone in its problems and no system is perfect, all make trade-off with regard to what they cover and what they cost. All three of the above systems are either private or public-private hybrids that bear lots of similarities to the US system –and to American reform proposals, making it clear that no matter what the outcome of the bills now before Congress, the challenges the US faces aren’t going to magically melt away.
There are no panaceas in either policy or medicine and those who believe there are have been duped. The lesson is clear: look before you leap –and look carefully.
